📘 Lexicon Entry: Presence

Short Definition
The first dimension of Wells’ “being with” framework involving physical proximity and genuine availability to others as foundational to relationship rather than optional addition.
Definition
The foundational dimension of authentic relationship that emphasizes physical proximity and genuine availability to others as essential rather than accidental aspects of genuine encounter. Drawing from Samuel Wells’ theological framework, presence constitutes the necessary foundation for all other relational dimensions including Attention, Mystery, and Participation. This concept challenges contemporary tendencies toward disembodied connection and service provision models that substitute resources for relationship. Grounded in incarnational theology, presence reflects the paradigm established by God’s embodied presence in Christ, where divine revelation occurs primarily through embodied presence rather than abstract communication. This theological alternative directly counters Practical Atheism by insisting that theological claims must be embodied in physical presence, and challenges digital substitution of virtual connection for authentic embodied relationship.
Category
Theological Alternative
Keywords
embodied theology, incarnational presence, relational foundation, physical proximity, authentic relationship, Wells framework, being with
Citation Guide
Geevarghese-Uffman, Craig. “Presence.” *Political Theology Lexicon*. https://www.commonlifepolitics.com/p/lexicon. Accessed [date].
Orthodox Alternatives
Embodied presence constitutes essential rather than optional aspect of authentic relationship
Divine revelation occurs primarily through embodied presence rather than abstract communication
Physical proximity enables genuine encounter that transcends mere information exchange
Availability to others reflects divine availability to humanity through incarnation
Vulnerability inherent in physical presence reflects divine self-giving in Christ
Mutated Position
Reduction of relationship to information exchange without embodied presence
Abstract theological claims disconnected from embodied community
Digital substitution of virtual connection for physical presence
Gnostic devaluation of material dimension of relationship
Service provision models that provide resources without relationship
Key Characteristics
Physical Proximity: Intentional geographic closeness that enables regular, sustained interaction
Genuine Availability: Emotional and temporal accessibility that prioritizes relationship over efficiency
Incarnational Foundation: Grounded in God’s embodied presence in Christ as theological paradigm
Relational Priority: Valued for its own sake rather than as means to other ends
Vulnerability Embrace: Acceptance of risk and exposure inherent in physical proximity
Theological Foundations
Incarnational Theology: God’s embodied presence in Christ establishes paradigm for human relationship
Trinitarian Presence: Divine persons existing in perfect mutual availability and presence
Sacramental Ontology: Material realities mediating spiritual presence through physical elements
Tabernacling Tradition: God’s choice to dwell among rather than apart from humanity
Biblical Foundation
Incarnation as "Word becoming flesh" establishing divine presence (John 1:14)
God’s tabernacling presence among Israel (Exodus 25:8)
Jesus’ physical touch in healing ministry (Mark 1:41)
Early church’s shared meals and physical gathering (Acts 2:42-47)
Paul’s desire for physical presence over letter-writing (1 Thessalonians 2:17-18)
Contemporary Expression
L’Arche Communities: Shared life with individuals with intellectual disabilities emphasizing mutual vulnerability through daily presence
Incarnational Mission: Long-term presence and language learning in cross-cultural contexts rather than short-term service trips
Intentional Communities: Residential communities practicing shared daily life across racial, economic, and social differences
Hospice Ministry: Accompaniment through suffering emphasizing presence rather than cure-focused intervention
Urban Ministry: Sustained presence in marginalized neighborhoods building relationships over time
Academic Research
Samuel Wells’ development of “being with” framework from urban ministry experience demonstrates how sustained presence enables authentic relationship beyond service delivery models
Jean Vanier’s L’Arche communities provide concrete evidence for how physical proximity and shared vulnerability create conditions for mutual transformation
Research on digital communication demonstrates limitations of virtual connection for developing trust, empathy, and deep relationship
Studies of incarnational mission approaches show greater cultural understanding and sustainable impact through long-term presence
Key Authors
Path Navigation
Related Theological Alternatives: Being With, Incarnational Presence, Trinitarian Participation
Key Mutations Addressed: Practical Atheism, Binary Apocalypticism
Related Dimensions: Attention, Mystery, Participation
Last Updated
May 25, 2025
Lex_entry_footer
Footer appended to all lexicon entries in Tana Publish
*This entry is part of the Political Theology Lexicon, accessible exclusively to subscribers. View the complete lexicon to explore related concepts and the full theoretical framework.*
Tana logo