📘 Lexicon Entry: Practical Atheism

Short Definition
A theological mutation where orthodox Christian beliefs are maintained intellectually but have no practical impact on daily life, decisions, or ethical behavior
Definition
Practical Atheism represents a theological mutation characterized by the disconnection between professed theological beliefs and lived practice. While maintaining orthodox doctrinal positions intellectually, this mutation functions as if God is absent from practical decision-making, ethical choices, and daily life. Unlike theoretical atheism which explicitly denies God’s existence, practical atheism affirms God’s reality while living as if divine presence and purposes are irrelevant to actual life. This mutation undermines the integration of faith and practice that characterizes authentic Christianity, creating compartmentalized religion that serves primarily social and cultural functions rather than transformative spiritual purposes. Practical atheism often provides the theological foundation for Dominative Christianism and MAGA Christianism, enabling the use of Christian identity for political purposes while avoiding the demanding ethical implications of actual discipleship.
Category
Theological Mutation
Keywords
theory-practice divide, compartmentalized faith, cultural Christianity, nominal belief, spiritual formation, discipleship, ethical integration
Citation Guide
Geevarghese-Uffman, Craig. “Practical Atheism.” *Political Theology Lexicon*. https://www.commonlifepolitics.com/p/lexicon. Accessed [date].
Orthodox Position
Faith and practice integrated through discipleship that transforms daily life
Theological beliefs expressed through ethical behavior and spiritual formation
Divine presence acknowledged through worship, prayer, and moral decision-making
Christianity as comprehensive way of life rather than compartmentalized belief system
Mutated Position
Orthodox beliefs maintained intellectually while having no practical impact on daily life
Faith compartmentalized away from business, politics, relationships, and ethical choices
Christian identity used primarily for social and cultural positioning rather than spiritual transformation
Reduction of Christianity to intellectual assent without embodied discipleship
Key Characteristics
Disconnection between professed beliefs and lived practice
Compartmentalization of faith away from practical decision-making
Use of Christian identity for social positioning without spiritual transformation
Resistance to ethical demands of gospel message
Historical Development
Emerged from Enlightenment separation of reason and faith
Reinforced by American individualism and privatization of religion
Accelerated by consumer culture and prosperity-focused spirituality
Institutionalized through cultural Christianity that emphasizes identity over transformation
Theological Distortions
Separation of justification from sanctification in daily life
Reduction of salvation to personal insurance policy rather than life transformation
Minimization of discipleship costs and ethical demands
Instrumentalization of faith for non-spiritual purposes
Biblical Misinterpretation
Ignoring Jesus’s call to take up the cross and follow him
Separating faith from works in ways that eliminate practical implications
Reducing great commission to cultural transmission rather than spiritual transformation
Missing integration of worship and justice throughout biblical narrative
Contemporary Expression
Business practices that contradict professed Christian values
Political allegiances that override gospel priorities
Lifestyle choices indistinguishable from secular materialism
Church attendance without life transformation or spiritual growth
MAGA Expression
Supporting policies that contradict Christian teaching about immigrants and refugees
Prioritizing political loyalty over gospel demands for truth-telling
Embracing narratives of vengeance and retribution while professing forgiveness
Using Christian identity to justify cultural dominance without embodying Christian virtues
Providential Expression
Claiming divine blessing for national policies while ignoring their impact on vulnerable populations
Asserting chosenness while avoiding ethical responsibilities that come with election
Reducing providence to divine endorsement of existing cultural arrangements
Separating God’s sovereignty from demands for justice and mercy
Cultural Impact
Undermining of Christian witness through hypocrisy and inconsistency
Reduction of Christianity to cultural marker rather than transformative faith
Alienation of seekers who observe disconnect between beliefs and behavior
Weakening of church’s prophetic voice in public life
Academic Research
Studies of belief-behavior gaps in American Christianity
Research on secularization and compartmentalization of religious faith
Analysis of cultural Christianity versus transformative discipleship
Key Authors
Dallas Willard
Lesslie Newbigin
Path Navigation
Key Mutations: Primitive Biblicism, Binary Apocalypticism, Tribal Epistemology
Contemporary Movements: Christian Nationalism
Theological Alternatives: Being With, Relational Receptivity
Historical Context: Civil Religion, Cotton Evangelicalism
Last Updated
May 22, 2025
Lex_entry_footer
Footer appended to all lexicon entries in Tana Publish
*This entry is part of the Political Theology Lexicon, accessible exclusively to subscribers. View the complete lexicon to explore related concepts and the full theoretical framework.*
Tana logo